
Last night, I was part of a proposal. One of my brothers in law, Jonathan, decided that he wanted to propose to his girlfriend, Rachel, in front of family and friends at their apartment. The crowd was easy to round up, as Rachel already invited us over to celebrate her birthday. (Note to my 7 followers: Rachel's birthday was this past Monday, so the day is not forever tarnished if something were to go awry. Not that I want it to, but I am a big proponent of NOT proposing on major or minor holidays or days of significance. For example, Christmas, Valentine's Day, the anniversary of the day I passed my road test...you get the picture). Sooo, originally Josh and I had plans which I don't even think he cancelled , but when Jonathan called us to say that he wanted us to be there for him we of course agreed in a heartbeat; family first! NOW, before I share with you how this proposal went down, I would like to reflect on the whole concept. It seems that whenever someone I know gets engaged, after I ask them what the ring looks like (I'm a girl and I like diamonds, SO WHAT?), the next question is, how did it happen? Or, if it is a male friend, how did you do it? Why has the proposal become such a big, dramatic, event where days and days of planning go into the asking of a 4 word question? My hypothesized, non-sociological educational background answer would be competition. What guy wants his girl to say, "Well, he pulled my by my hair, dragged me to the bedroom and said, "You are mine, bitch?" What guy wants his girl to say, well, "He asked me to order Chinese takeout, and when he threw in his request for an egg roll, he asked me to marry him." Or perhaps it is because the male in question wants his future wife to remember this day forever, which, if she really loves you, she will, because she so badly wants to spend her life with you. I am a cynic when it comes to proposals and weddings, but before I get into that, here is a brief history on the matter.
Lets start with Adam and Eve. Eve was not asked if she wanted to get married, let alone if she liked men. As the story goes, God created Eve from Adam's rib, and the two lived happily ever after. I am clearly dumbing down this story, but it was not as if Adam or Eve had any other options but to be together during this time in history. The options they did have are disgusting and I am just not going there today.
Based upon the few moments of research I did, our primitive ancestors did not pair up for the sake of love; the larger the tribe, the more protected the people were and the better chance they had for survival. Loyalty was pledged to the tribe, rather than an individual.
In the 19th century, a declaration of love was the equivalent of a proposal. If that rule still existed today, we would all be polygamists! When it comes to an arranged marriage, there is no asking amongst the couple that is being betrothed. Yet, today, at least in my small microcosm I exist in, proposals are a big deal. A friend of mine was proposed to after a series of scavenger hunt style activities. Another one was brought to the beach for a romantic proposal, only she was annoyed because there were so many kids there on a camp field trip. My cousin was brought to Manhattan to go for the horse and carriage ride for "the question." A girl I worked with was called to the principal's office, thinking she was in trouble, but instead her fiance walked out of the principal's closet with a ring in his hand.
My own experiences range from the dramatic to what i like to call "the caveman" style. If you don't already know, Josh is husband numero dos. He is the keeper. My first husband, not so much. Years back, when I was younger and waaaayyy stupid, I was with a guy for a while. As my friends paired off, married, and began having kids, I was sucked into the idea that I just had to marry this guy. I assumed that the nagging thoughts in the back of my head would be resolved with two little words (I do) and that marriage would just make everything better. Needless to say, it was not a shock to me when marriage made everything so much worse. But, the proposal was something to remember. We had gone to Miami for a few days. The first night, we went to dinner. When we went back to our hotel, I walked into the room first. It was dark. I had to walk across the room to turn on the light. When I did, ex was on bended knee amongst scattered rose petals asking for my hand in marriage. He actually listened to me for once and presented me with the ring I had obsessed over for years.
Flash forward about 4 years (I move quick). New Years Eve of 2008, Josh tells me that we are going to be together forever. Now, what do girls want to hear? The ones I know want to hear that together forever equates to marriage. So at this point in my life, I tell Josh this. And he very dramatically tells me that he wants to marry me and has begun saving for a ring, only I have now ruined things by asking what his intentions are (we had a good laugh over that last night). Josh then had made up his mind that he wanted to get married, called everyone he knew to tell them, and by April 4, 2008, I was Mrs. Shapiro. The way he actually proposed was like this:
SCENE: Living room of apartment. February/March-ish. I am sitting on the couch, either "fake shopping" on the internet or doing work for Annual Reviews.
Enter from the front door (the only door): Josh
Josh (serious and determined): I want to marry you. Let's get married.
Me (giggly, excited, yet slightly reserved): Okay. Should I call my parents?
So, I had the romance, I had the "caveman" proposal. And you know what? The one that is most memorable is the one from Josh, because we are still together. In the scheme of things, the proposal, the wedding, the glamour the glitz...they are not what is important at all. Marriage is about the couple and their commitment. Is it nice to look at pictures from those days? Of course, but photo albums get shoved to the back of the bookcase because the reality of marriage is the day to day, not the poofy white dress and drama over what kind of cake filling to get or peonies versus roses or hair up or down or.......I digress.
So here is how Jonathan proposed. Inspired by our cousins, the Stegers, who love to create songs and poems for big events, Jon wrote a poem that related to our history with Rachel. Presenters included a few close friends, our nieces, my in-laws, Josh and Jake and Jason, my other two bros-in law. We delivered our lines and Jonathan ended the poem on bended knee, with the ring. Rachel said yes.
And like I always do, whether at a wedding or engagement party, here is what is running through my head:
Me: "I hope they are happy."
Fade out from scene to the tune of Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust".